Voting for the October Screenshot Competition has now Closed

[dbcunnz]

Voting is now open for the October Screenshot Competition and voting closes midnight Tuesday the 5th November

One Rule only Do not vote for your own entry

[Ian Warren]

Now who snuck that tigger in he came in under my radar

[Adrian Brausch]

Lots of awesome shots this month but I have to say it was pretty damn difficult to choose because what may be a great shot to look at isnt always going to make a good banner,...you guys need to think about lighting,..size of your subject,..whether it will fit into a banner configuration once cropped. At the end of the day I chose the screen I liked best,..whether it will make a good banner Im not so sure...we will see... . Good work tho all who contributed.

[toprob]

QUOTE (Adrian Brausch @ Nov 1 2013,9:34 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Lots of awesome shots this month but I have to say it was pretty damn difficult to choose because what may be a great shot to look at isnt always going to make a good banner,...you guys need to think about lighting,..size of your subject,..whether it will fit into a banner configuration once cropped. At the end of the day I chose the screen I liked best,..whether it will make a good banner Im not so sure...we will see... . Good work tho all who contributed.

The idea has always been that this is first and foremost a screenshot competition, the banner is an added incentive, but the banner shouldn't be the final goal. The final goal should be a great screenshot. The banner isn't there to display the winning screenshot, but to promote the forum. It's up to the banner designer to figure out how that'll work, but his goal should always be to get an eye-catching banner.

I remember one issue I had with a banner, where I cropped the aircraft to fit the forum name in nicely. Someone (it might not have been the winner) pointed out that I could have left the aircraft in complete, and that somehow I was obligated to if I could do so. Since this would have resulted in an ugly banner, I wouldn't do this. The banner is a very important graphic element on the forum, so it needs to be designed as such.

Things may have changed with a change of banner designer, but I would still recommend that the winner should be the best screenshot, not the best banner.

[Ian Warren]

QUOTE (toprob @ Nov 1 2013,1:01 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Things may have changed with a change of banner designer, but I would still recommend that the winner should be the best screenshot, not the best banner.

YEP ! .. IT s a screenshot competition , how it is edited later is the easy part .. the fun part is doing it !

[Adrian Brausch]

yep rightly so Rob n Ian, I stand corrected ,..oh and I did vote for my favourite screenshot,..and it wasnt based on whether it would make a good banner...

[AlisterC]

I think this month everyone who entered (in my mind) has done an amazing job. Master artist standard all round. Well done all. I only have one vote, but for the other 21, consider this statement one more virtual vote to your tally!

[emfrat]

Well, Doug only has one vote, the same as the rest of us...but I do try to arrange things so that if one of mine happens to win, it will be easy for Doug to make a great banner from it - he does enough work for us as it is.
The voting so far shows that the standard is improving all the time, and that no-one can expect a walkover. That's how it should be, in my less-than-humble opinion

[deeknow]

QUOTE (toprob @ Nov 1 2013,1:01 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The idea has always been that this is first and foremost a screenshot competition, the banner is an added incentive, but the banner shouldn't be the final goal. The final goal should be a great screenshot.

Not the way I look at it personally, the shots are nearly always great and theres plenty to choose from so I always give decent weighting to something I think would work as a banner.

[Ian Warren]

I think looking at current votes , due Doug going to the effort changing entries by number appears to get a great and more honest spread ...

[dbcunnz]

Come on all you members that haven't voted yet get your A into G as voting closes at midnight tonight

[dbcunnz]

Regarding images and the banner it would make it far easier if members where to pause and take two screen shots one for the competition and then zoom out and take another that can be cropped for the banner that is unless their original shot can be easily cropped into a banner

[Ian Warren]

Time to wrap a the infamous 'Tea Towel' on me head and scream Ala lala ala la ..... in English means ennie mennie minnie mo ...

[dbcunnz]

The voting has now closed and a big congratulations to toprob